Document Type
Article
Publication Date
5-2026
ISSN
0006-8047
Publisher
Boston University School of Law
Language
en-US
Abstract
The professors are the enemy. Professors are the enemy. Write that on the blackboard 100 times and never forget it.
—President Richard Nixon, 19721
[I]f any of us wants to do the things we want to do[,] . . . we have to honestly and aggressively attack the universities in this country.
—J.D. Vance, 20212
October 7, 2023 was many things. One of those things was a lucky break for the Heritage Foundation (“Heritage”). For decades, Heritage and its allied think tanks, donors, and officials had labored to discredit and, if possible, take over higher education in the United States. This project accelerated following 2020’s racial reckoning. In states like Florida, North Carolina, and Texas, GOP officials intensified strategic campaigns to wrest control of their public universities by censoring curricular content,3 eroding faculty protections, and transforming university governing boards from non-partisan bodies into an arm of the state’s Republican Party apparatus.
By fall 2023, the architects of these campaigns were celebrating significant victories in Republican-controlled states. But it was never clear how a movement animated by nostalgia for a pre-Civil Rights America could puncture universities in liberal strongholds like New York, Massachusetts, and California. Then October 7 happened.
For folks like Christopher Rufo, the right-wing activist who turned critical race theory (“CRT”) “toxic,”5 the campus unrest that followed Hamas’ attack on Israel was an opportunity to exploit.6 Within days, the same actors leading the charge against CRT had integrated calculated accusations about “antisemitism on campus” into their talking points.7 This pivot capitalized on real conflicts emerging on university campuses8 and a pre-existing academic and cultural landscape that cast Palestine solidarity as “presumptively antisemitic.”9 The rhetorical turn to antisemitism also harnessed a contingent yet potent alignment between far right groups, legacy Jewish organizations, Democratic politicians and university insiders—including certain prominent Jewish faculty...
...President Trump’s desire to erode university independence follows decades of conservative backlash to the liberal underpinnings of higher education and the systemic analyses of power they incubate. Today’s attacks trace to “Massive Resistance” against federally mandated desegregation and the antiracist, anticapitalist, and anticolonial ideas that fueled the Civil Rights Movement.25 Reflecting on that period, Professor Asad Rahim has detailed how Supreme Court Justice Louis Powell was “consumed by a suspicion that White and Black radicals, influenced by communists, had teamed up to plot a revolution that would dismantle capitalism and overthrow American democracy.”26 Justice Powell specifically warned that left extremists, who he termed the “‘hate America’ left,” aimed to “establish the campus as the principal base of revolution.”27 Justice Powell saw diversity—namely, intellectual diversity—as an antidote to left-wing “radicalism.”
President Ronald Reagan shared Justice Powell’s anxieties. As California’s governor in 1969, Reagan cast the prior decade of student protest as “one of the great tragedies of modern history.”29 “It seems incomprehensible,” he wrote, “that a portion of our population, including some students, some faculty members and outsiders, is attempting to overthrow our democratic way of life.”30 Reagan and the broader conservative movement responded by defunding California’s public universities. 31 Akin to racist myths about welfare recipients, Reagan wielded “culture war” attacks to justify unpopular funding cuts.
We have since witnessed decades of often-bipartisan austerity alongside rising student and institutional debt, growing private donor dependency and influence, waning employment opportunities, and widening inequality in educational access.33 These coalescing dynamics continue to expose universities to public criticism and external interference.
Legitimate criticism has dovetailed with conservative campaigns to sow public distrust and discredit higher education’s basic integrationist gains. 34 Following handwringing over “political correctness” in the 1990s and 2000s, a chorus of right-wing and centrist pundits and entities sowed moral panic about campus “free speech crises” during the 2010s—often pitting the blame on DEI. 35 Reflecting on these dynamics, Jason Stanley observed how the mainstream media “waged a decade-long propaganda campaign against American universities.”36 This includes outlets like The New York Times and The Atlantic, both of which helped naturalize misplaced and reductionist narratives about “oversensitive” students and the universities that “coddled” them, and derided the alleged source of this “illiberal” sensibility: too much “diversity, inclusion, and anti-excellence.”
Attacks on higher education again intensified alongside the reactionary right’s broader backlash to 2020’s racial reckoning. These attacks further intensified following October 7, 2023.
Recommended Citation
Jonathan Feingold & Isaac Kamola,
MAGA's Blue State Strategy: How Democrats and University Leaders Helped the Reactionary Right Weaponize Antisemitism Against Higher Education
,
106
Boston University Law Review
1127
(2026).
Available at:
https://scholarship.law.bu.edu/faculty_scholarship/4304
Included in
Civil Rights and Discrimination Commons, Constitutional Law Commons, Education Law Commons, Law and Politics Commons, Law and Society Commons
