POV: Should Parents Be Charged for a Child's Crimes? That's the Wrong Solution

Document Type

Opinion

Publication Date

9-9-2024

Publisher

Boston University's Marketing & Communications Office

Language

en-US

Abstract

Recently, a 14-year-old at Apalachee High School in Winder, Ga., killed two classmates and two teachers in a familiar tragedy of missed warning signs and easy access to weapons. But local prosecutors charging his father with murder is a different kind of unfolding tragedy.

Earlier this year, prosecutors brought similar charges against Jennifer and James Crumbley in Michigan, although for a lesser crime of manslaughter, after their teenage son killed four students in 2021. Just as with Georgia, there were exceptional circumstances in that case that supported a prosecution.

Nevertheless legal scholars, including myself, worried about the escalation of criminalizing parents as accomplices for their children’s acts. At the time, Michigan, like Georgia, did not mandate weapons storage. Unable to charge the parents with lower offenses, prosecutors decided to hold the parents responsible for the actual killings, because they did not take extra safeguards despite warning signs of mental health issues. Unfortunately this approach is a poor substitute for firearm safeguards and mental health support. These prosecutions are concerning because holding people criminally responsible for the actions of others expands the already wide net of criminal responsibility.

This document is currently not available here.

Publisher Link

Share

COinS